1993-95 PRIORITIES AND PROGRESS UNDER THE GREAT LAKES WATER QUALITY AGREEMENT


Chapter Two:Great Lakes Science Advisory Board


2.2 Human Health in Ecosystem Health: Issues of Meaning and Measurement


2.2.4 Indicator Selection Criteria


Table 2:

Ecosystem Health Indicator Selection Criteria Developed by the Council of Great Lakes Research Managers


Biologically relevant *** i.e. important in maintaining a balanced biological community
Socially relevant *** of obvious value to and observable by shareholders or predictive of a measure that is . . .
Sensitive *** to stressors without an all-or non-response or extreme natural variability
Broadly applicable *** to many stressors or sites
Diagnostic *** of the particular stressor causing the problem
Measurable *** i.e. capable of being operationally defined and measured, using a standard procedure with documented performance and low measurement error
Interpretable *** i.e. capable of distinguishing acceptable from unacceptable conditions in a scientifically and legally defensible way
Cost-effective *** i.e. inexpensive to measure, providing the maximum amount of information per unit effort
Integrative *** summarizing information from many unmeasured indicators, one for which . . .
Historical data are available *** to define nominative variability, trends and possibly acceptable and unacceptable conditions
Anticipatory *** i.e. capable of providing an indication of degradation before serious harm has occurred, early warning
Nondestructive *** of the ecosystem, one with potential for . . .
Continuity *** in measurement over time, of an . . .
Appropriate scale *** for the management problem being addressed. For the International Joint Commission, there are three relevant spatial scales: the Area of Concern, lakewide management and the basin ecosystem and many appropriate temporal scales
Not redundant with other measured indicators *** i.e. providing unique information
Timely *** i.e. providing information quickly enough to initiate effective management action before unacceptable damage has occurred