Based on a Workshop to Evaluate Data Interpretation Tools used to Make Sediment Management Decisions held at the Great Lakes Institute for Environmental Research at the University of Windsor on December 1-2, 1998
Prepared by: Gail Krantzberg, John Hartig, Lisa Maynard, Kelly Burch, and Carol Ancheta
Sediment Priority Action Committee
Great Lakes Water Quality Board
1999
TABLE OF CONTENTS
| List of Tables and Figures | ||
| Preface | ||
| I. | Executive Summary | |
| II. | Introduction | |
| III. | Synthesis and Findings
The Imperative: Restoring Beneficial Uses How to Best Interpret the Data | |
| IV. | Concluding Remarks and Recommendations | |
| V. | Literature Cited | |
| VI. | Appendices: | |
| Appendix 1 | Workshop Format and Agenda | |
| Appendix 2 | List of Workshop Participants | |
| Appendix 3 | Sediment Assessment and Remediation: Ontario's Approach by Rein Jaagumagi and Deo Persaud | |
| Appendix 4 | Thunder Bay Creosote Cleanup: A Case Study in the Application of Ontario's Approach to Sediment Assessment and Remediation by Rein Jaagumagi and Donna Bedard | |
| Appendix 5 | Decision-Making for Sediment: Numeric Biological Guidelines by Trefor Reynoldson | |
| Appendix 6 | Ecological Risk Assessment Applied in the Saginaw River/Saginaw Bay by Lisa Williams | |
| Appendix 7 | The Application of Human Health Risk Assessment Techniques at Sediment Contaminated Sites under the Superfund Program by Marian Olsen | |
| Appendix 8 | U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Dredged Material Evaluation and Assessment Procedures by Robert Engler; and Testing and Evaluation Procedures for Great Lakes Dredged Material Evaluations Developed by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the U.S. Corps of Engineers by Jan Miller | |
| Appendix 9 | 1994/1995 St. Clair River Sediment Program Defining Spatial Extent and Environmental Conditions by Tim Moran and Scott Munro | |
| Appendix 10 | Trenton Channel/Detroit River Sediment Assessment and Remediation by Russell Kreis | |
| Appendix 11 | A Framework for Interpreting Narrative Sediment Quality Standards by Jim Keating | |
| Appendix 12 | Ecological Risk Assessment for the Contaminated Harbor Sediment Adjacent to the Ashland, Wisconsin Lakefront Property - Kreher Park by Bob Paulson | |
| Appendix 13 | The SED-TOX Index for the Assessment and Ranking of Sediment Hazard Potential: How is it Useful for Decision-Making? by Manon Bombardier | |
| Appendix 14 | Contaminated Sediment: When is Cleanup Required? The Washington State Approach by Teresa Michelsen | |
| Appendix 15 | Application of Computer Modeling and Biomonitoring in Decision Making for the St. Clair River Area of Concern by John Alexander McCorquodale, Maciej Tomczak, and Gordon Douglass Haffner | |
| Appendix 16 | Report from Breakout Group A | |
| Appendix 17 | Report from Breakout Group B | |
| Appendix 18 | Sediment Priority Action Committee Membership | |
| Table 1. | The interrelationships among sediment management outcome indicators and use impairments as defined in the Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement |
| Table 2. | A matrix of data interpretation tools and references for making a sediment management decision beyond source control to restore beneficial uses as defined in the Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement |
| Table 3. | A checklist of key elements to consider in making a sediment management decision beyond source control |
| Appendix 3 | |
| Table 1. | Provincial Sediment Quality Guidelines for metals and nutrients |
| Table 2. | Provincial Sediment Quality Guidelines for organic compounds |
| Appendix 5 | |
| Table 1. | Summary of taxonomic composition of benthic invertebrates at Group 2 reference sites and 12 Cornwall test sites |
| Table 2. | Summary of sediment quality based on invertebrate community structure, sediment toxicity, and sediment chemistry |
| Appendix 6 | |
| Table 1. | Components of the Saginaw Natural Resource Damage Assessment Settlement |
| Appendix 12 | |
| Table 1. | PAH sediment concentrations and related toxicity units at the study sites |
| Figure 1. | A generalized flowchart which can be used to help make a sediment management decision regarding whether or not to take action beyond source control |
| Appendix 3 | |
| Figure 1. | Application of Provincial Sediment Quality Guidelines to sediment assessment |